Recent discussions among hockey analysts Chris Johnston and Darren Dreger have shed light on the trade speculation surrounding Toronto Maple Leafs forward Matthew Knies, particularly in the lead-up to the trade deadline, with rumors of interest from the Montreal Canadiens.
Addressing the persistent question of whether Knies’ name was actively discussed in potential deals between the Leafs and Habs, Johnston confirmed that the Maple Leafs indeed engaged in discussions involving Matthew Knies. However, he cautioned that the extent to which these talks progressed might have been “overstated,” suggesting they were not close to finalizing a deal.
Johnston elaborated on why Knies would be a subject of trade talks. Despite not being the team’s best player, Knies is considered one of Toronto’s most valuable assets due to his contract status, which offers no protection, unlike other players with no-movement clauses whose market value is limited. Given the team’s season trajectory, it was logical for the Leafs to listen to inquiries about Knies to gauge his market value. While Johnston doesn’t believe a deal was imminent, he noted that “everything was on the table effectively,” and the team gained an understanding of his worth, a situation that could be revisited in the future.
Dreger echoed Johnston’s sentiment, explaining that while most teams have “near-untouchable” players, general managers frequently make “what if” calls, especially when they perceive a team’s direction. This was precisely the case with the Montreal Canadiens, who likely inquired about the hypothetical package required to acquire Knies. Dreger speculates that the Maple Leafs’ response would have involved a substantial return, potentially including assets like Michael Hage and multiple first-round draft picks, indicating that such a comprehensive offer would prompt a serious conversation. However, he confirmed that a proposal of that magnitude was never tabled.
He added that other teams also made inquiries, albeit fewer. Drawing a comparison, Dreger noted that if the Maple Leafs had explored acquiring a player like Robert Thomas from the St. Louis Blues, the expected return would certainly involve Knies, alongside other assets. Crucially, both analysts emphasized that Toronto was never actively “shopping” Matthew Knies. Instead, the situation revolved around other general managers initiating contact to understand what it might take to even consider parting with the promising forward, a significant distinction from actively trying to move a player.
