The world of chess, currently experiencing unprecedented growth particularly in the online sphere, finds itself grappling with a delicate situation involving two prominent grandmasters. As the sport`s global governing body, FIDE has issued a statement addressing the public dispute between GM Vladimir Kramnik and GM David Navara, seeking to clarify its position and call for a resolution.
At the heart of the matter lies the critical issue of fair play. FIDE emphasizes its unwavering commitment to upholding integrity in both over-the-board and online competitions. In this context, methods proposed by GM Kramnik for statistically evaluating fair play have drawn attention. FIDE acknowledges that these methods merit careful examination and has announced the formation of a dedicated task force specifically to evaluate their practical applicability. GM Kramnik has been invited to formally present the specifics of his approach and supporting data for official assessment.
However, FIDE`s statement pivots from the technical evaluation to express grave concerns regarding the *manner* in which GM Kramnik has publicly presented his arguments. The governing body highlights that his public discourse constitutes a clear narrative which, originating from a former World Champion, carries significant weight. FIDE warns that this approach can inflict considerable harm on the chess community and potentially be “ruinous” for the careers and well-being of specific players.
This public discourse has, unfortunately, culminated in a legal confrontation. The statement notes that the situation has significantly affected GM David Navara, a respected member of the chess community, and has led to GM Kramnik filing a defamation lawsuit against him.
FIDE takes a strong stance in defense of GM Navara. The statement unequivocally asserts that throughout his career, GM Navara has cultivated an unquestionable reputation as a **paragon of fair play**. The community is well aware, according to FIDE, of David Navara`s sensitivity and integrity, making him particularly vulnerable to implications of unfair play.
Without delving into the legal or stylistic merits of the specific statements exchanged, FIDE prioritizes mutual respect and empathy among colleagues. In a clear and direct appeal, FIDE states its firm conviction that the lawsuit filed against GM Navara **should be withdrawn as soon as possible**. This action is deemed essential for the benefit of the entire chess community.
The FIDE Management Board expresses its sincere hope that GM Kramnik will take this step, describing it as “morally justified” and one they believe will be widely welcomed by the broader chess world. The statement underscores FIDE`s commitment to fair play while also navigating the complexities of public discourse and the potential impact on individual reputations within the competitive chess landscape.
