“`html
The dust is settling on another frenetic NHL offseason, a period when hopes are traded, contracts are signed, and the rosters for the upcoming season begin to take shape. While the previous season saw a familiar outcome with the Florida Panthers once again hoisting the Stanley Cup, the landscape underneath is perpetually shifting.
Every summer brings a flurry of player movement through trades and free agency, altering team dynamics and prospects. This year, perhaps fewer “superstar” names changed addresses compared to some past offseasons, but the sheer volume of transactions still creates significant shifts in team composition. The big question remains: who navigated the choppy waters of the offseason to significantly improve their roster, and who saw valuable assets walk out the door?
To answer this, we can turn to analytics. A useful tool for assessing player impact is Goals Above Replacement (GAR). Simplified, GAR estimates a player`s overall contribution in terms of goals compared to a hypothetical average “replacement level” player in the same situation. Analyzing the net change in 3-year weighted GAR for incoming versus outgoing players provides a data-driven perspective on which teams added the most value, and which teams experienced the most significant losses.
Let`s examine the teams that, according to this metric, had the most impactful offseasons, starting with those who added the most net value.
The Ascendants: Teams Bolstered by Offseason Moves
San Jose Sharks: +22.0 Net 3-Year Weighted GAR
After consecutive seasons at the bottom of the league standings, the only way is up, and San Jose is certainly trying. While still a long-term rebuild, the Sharks made savvy additions, particularly on defense with Dmitry Orlov and John Klingberg, and in net with Alex Nedeljkovic. These veteran acquisitions provide crucial support and structure around their promising young core, notably future cornerstone Macklin Celebrini. By adding established value without sacrificing future assets, San Jose quietly positioned itself for a significant step towards respectability.
Anaheim Ducks: +17.7 Net 3-Year Weighted GAR
Much like their Californian counterparts, the Ducks are focused on building for the future but weren`t afraid to make moves that immediately improve the roster. While parting ways with long-time goaltender John Gibson and dynamic forward Trevor Zegras might seem significant, the emergence of young goaltender Lukáš Dostál lessened the impact of Gibson`s departure, and Zegras`s injury issues made his exit less detrimental by the numbers. The additions of forwards Chris Kreider and Mikael Granlund add much-needed offensive support and experience to complement young talents like Mason McTavish and Leo Carlsson. It`s a calculated risk, especially with the controversial hiring of coach Joel Quenneville, but one that immediately improves the team`s on-ice product based on these metrics.
Seattle Kraken: +13.1 Net 3-Year Weighted GAR
After a slight dip in defensive performance last season, Seattle addressed this need while also adding offensive punch. Mason Marchment stands out as a key addition, bringing both physicality and consistent goal production (topping 20 goals in recent seasons), along with strong defensive analytics for a forward. The acquisition of defenseman Ryan Lindgren further solidifies the blue line. With minimal significant subtractions, the Kraken enjoyed a solid, if unspectacular, offseason that should help them rebound under new leadership.
Montreal Canadiens: +11.1 Net 3-Year Weighted GAR
The Canadiens exceeded expectations last season, making the playoffs ahead of schedule with a burgeoning young roster. They capitalized on this momentum by swinging a major trade for defenseman Noah Dobson, one of the premier young blueliners in the game. Dobson immediately elevates their defense corps and power play. Adding forward Zack Bolduc, coming off a strong season, further boosts their offensive potential. Their losses were manageable, making this a clear win for a team whose future seems to be arriving faster than anticipated.
Vegas Golden Knights: +8.7 Net 3-Year Weighted GAR
Never ones to shy away from a big splash, the Golden Knights landed perhaps the biggest name on the move this summer: Mitch Marner. His elite offensive production (102 points last season) is a massive addition to an already potent forward group led by Jack Eichel. The cost was significant, both in terms of salary and the loss of depth players like Nicolas Roy, but GM Kelly McCrimmon clearly believes this move pushes Vegas closer to another championship. They were already a top team by GAR last season; adding Marner makes them even stronger by this measure.
Nashville Predators: +8.7 Net 3-Year Weighted GAR
After a promising setup faltered last season, Nashville is back on the list of gainers, though with less fanfare this time. Their additions focused on bolstering a defense that struggled, bringing in reliable players like Nick Perbix and Nicolas Hague. While not star-studded moves, they address a key weakness. Success in Nashville also heavily depends on their established stars finding their form after a disappointing collective performance. The moves suggest a desire to contend again without undergoing a full-scale rebuild.
The Descendants: Teams Facing Value Erosion
Dallas Stars: -25.3 Net 3-Year Weighted GAR
The Stars led the league in value lost this offseason, compounding an already turbulent summer that included firing a coach who took them to three straight conference finals. While their core remains elite (Oettinger, Robertson, Rantanen, etc.), they saw a significant turnover in their supporting cast, losing key contributors like Mason Marchment, Mikael Granlund, Evgenii Dadonov, and Cody Ceci. Team management clearly felt the previous group had reached its ceiling, but time will tell if this level of disruption leads to improvement or instability for a team aiming for the Cup.
Edmonton Oilers: -13.1 Net 3-Year Weighted GAR
Another year, another Cup Final loss for the Oilers, despite having two of the game`s best players in McDavid and Draisaitl. The offseason saw several players depart, including Corey Perry, Viktor Arvidsson, Evander Kane, and Connor Brown. While Andrew Mangiapane was added, his value based on this metric isn`t enough to offset the losses. Perhaps most notably, the Oilers did not make a significant move to upgrade their goaltending despite struggles in the playoffs. Relying on the core to simply be better is one strategy, but analytics suggest the roster, on the whole, is weaker entering the season.
Toronto Maple Leafs: -12.3 Net 3-Year Weighted GAR
The biggest story in Toronto was the departure of star winger Mitch Marner, a foundational piece of their “Core Four.” While they recouped some value by acquiring a solid two-way center in Nicolas Roy as part of the Marner deal, and added winger Matias Maccelli (who has bounce-back potential), the net loss in established production is significant. The Maple Leafs still possess immense top-end talent, but losing a player of Marner`s caliber necessitates adjustments and raises questions about the team`s depth and chemistry moving forward.
New York Rangers: -9.3 Net 3-Year Weighted GAR
The Rangers also had a busy offseason marked by both coaching changes (Mike Sullivan replacing Peter Laviolette) and significant roster turnover. While they brought in defensemen like Vladislav Gavrikov, who is coming off a career-best season by GAR, they also saw valuable players depart, notably long-time Rangers Chris Kreider and K`Andre Miller. While both had down seasons recently, their combined value over the last three years is substantial. The Rangers are banking on internal improvements from their existing stars to counteract the loss of established value.
Winnipeg Jets: -7.4 Net 3-Year Weighted GAR
The Jets are a fascinating case. They defied many analytical models last season en route to a Presidents` Trophy, but some felt their success wasn`t entirely sustainable. Losing skilled winger Nikolaj Ehlers (who signed with Carolina) represents a significant blow to their offense, which saw a surprising jump last season. While they added players like Gustav Nyquist, the net loss in established GAR value, particularly upfront, aligns with predictions that Winnipeg might face some regression next season after their dream run.
Colorado Avalanche: -7.4 Net 3-Year Weighted GAR
Since their 2022 Cup victory, the Avalanche have seen their depth eroded due to salary cap constraints and player departures. This offseason continued that trend, with valuable forwards like Charlie Coyle and Jonathan Drouin, and defenseman Ryan Lindgren, leaving the team. While adding veteran defenseman Brent Burns brings experience and some offensive upside, he`s not the player he once was. The Avs still boast an elite core, but the continued loss of supporting talent, as indicated by their net GAR, makes their path back to contention arguably steeper.
Analytics provide a powerful lens through which to view the offseason`s impact. The GAR metric helps quantify the value added or lost, highlighting the teams that made the most significant roster changes by this measure. While teams like San Jose and Anaheim made major strides from a low base, others like Vegas and Montreal enhanced already promising situations. Conversely, perennial contenders like Dallas, Edmonton, and Toronto faced significant departures, necessitating strategic re-tooling.
Of course, hockey isn`t played on spreadsheets. Chemistry, coaching, player development, unexpected breakouts, and sheer luck all play vital roles. The data provides a predictive layer, but the true impact of these offseason shifts will only be revealed when the puck drops in the fall. Until then, we`re left to analyze the numbers and speculate on how these newly minted rosters will fare in the quest for the Stanley Cup.
“`
